On our way home from Wendy’s this afternoon, we (myself, Abby and Caroline) were listening to the local Christian radio station when the song “I Am A Friend of God” came on. There is nothing necessarily wrong with this song and the lyrics sufficiently reflect Biblical theology. However, this was the version performed by Philips, Craig & Dean — the popular contemporary Christian trio that has maintained a dominant place in Christian music for over a decade.
So, by now you’re thinking, “what’s the big deal?” right?? Here’s the problem, PCD are blatantly oneness. If you are reading this and do not know what the term “oneness” means, read this (it is a long read, but well worth it). In short, “oneness” reflects a denial of the historically orthodox doctrine of the Trinity as revealed in Scripture. Oneness theology is ancient modalism in the 21st century — meaning that God is not most definitely 3 in 1 and 1 in 3, but that He “appears” in the forms of Father, Son and Holy Spirit at various times. It is an ancient heresy that has plagued the church since the third century and has repeatedly been debunked.
Anyway, so PCD are “oneness pentecostals” which I define as an erroneous and heretical group. The Trinity is a core doctrine of the historic Christian faith and one cannot deny or distort it and still remain within Biblical Christianity. When I recognized that PCD was performing this song, I turned the station and Abby said, “Hey, I like that song. What’s wrong with it?” I explained to her that nothing was wrong with the song, but plenty was wrong with the singers. I told her that they deny the Trinity and she said “Well they’re just falsies!” What she meant of course was that they were “false teachers” as she has heard me use that phrase on numerous occasions.
I went on to explain to her why it is important to draw the line at certain points. There are many things that Christians can disagree on, but the Trinity is not one of them. I recently had a friend post on his Facebook “doctrine divides, but purpose unites.” To that I would respond, some doctrines are worth dividing over, and this is most certainly one of them. For a more thorough examination of PCD and their erroneous beliefs, read this.
On to the other issue of how has PCD remained so mainstream within Christian music yet hold to heretical beliefs (not only denial of the Trinity, but also that speaking in tongues is necessary for salvation). Do they sound so good that we are willing to throw down the Biblical standard of doctrinal purity just to hear them sing?? That is a question we should give some very serious thought.